Jewelry Store Near MeNew YorkDutchess CountyPoughkeepsieRaymond Avenue
39 Raymond Ave, Poughkeepsie, NY 12603, USA
Just stopped by Zimmer Brothers Jewelry in Poughkeepsie, NY, and I was honestly baffled by the experience. I brought in a 1/10 oz Gold Eagle (MS-70) and a 1/4 oz Platinum Eagle (MS-70) for appraisal. The lady at the front was very kind and professional, but when she came back with the offer from the guy in the back—hidden away like some mystery appraiser—I couldn’t believe it. They offered $175 for the gold coin, which is low to begin with, and then a shocking $25 for the platinum coin. That’s just insane considering its actual melt value, let alone the grade. The front desk rep was sweet and understanding, but whoever appraised those coins clearly doesn’t know—or care—about real value.
For residents across the New York region, and particularly in the Hudson Valley, finding a jewelry store that combines a wide selection with personalized service and expert craftsmanship is key. In Poughkeepsie, Zimmer Brothers Jewelers has long been a familiar name, recognized for its local presence and a range of services from custom design to repairs. This article aims to provide a clear, engaging, and informative overview of Zimmer Brothers Jewelers, shedding light on their offerings, accessibility, and what customers can expect from their experience.
Zimmer Brothers Jewelers presents itself as a local jewelry establishment rooted in the Poughkeepsie community. As a long-standing business, they cater to a diverse clientele with various jewelry needs, from significant life purchases like engagement rings to intricate repairs of cherished family heirlooms. Customer reviews offer a mixed, yet insightful, perspective on their operations. While one review highlighted a frustrating experience with coin appraisal, noting a significant discrepancy in the offered price for gold and platinum coins compared to their market value, another review provides a strong counter-narrative, praising their custom work and repair services. This customer "absolutely loved" their experience, stating that Zimmer Brothers "exceeded my expectations" when resizing a family heirloom ring and swapping out a gem. They emphasized the reasonable pricing for the amazing work and turnaround time, affirming their decision to "shop local for our jewelry repair" and expressing intent to return for future needs, highly recommending them for "custom work." This contrasting feedback suggests that while they may not be the primary destination for precious metal bullion appraisal or sales, their expertise truly shines in the realm of custom jewelry design and repair, where their dedicated service and craftsmanship leave a lasting positive impression.
Zimmer Brothers Jewelers is conveniently situated at 39 Raymond Ave, Poughkeepsie, NY 12603, USA. Raymond Avenue is a well-known thoroughfare in Poughkeepsie, making the store easily identifiable and accessible for residents within the city and from surrounding areas in Dutchess County. Its location contributes to its role as a local and convenient option for community members seeking jewelry services.
For New Yorkers, accessibility is a crucial factor when choosing local businesses. Zimmer Brothers Jewelers' location on Raymond Avenue offers good connectivity for various modes of transportation in Poughkeepsie. For those traveling by car, Raymond Avenue provides straightforward navigation, and while specific parking details aren't provided, local businesses in this area typically have nearby parking options or street parking. Poughkeepsie is served by major roads, ensuring easy driving access from other towns in the Hudson Valley. For individuals relying on public transport, the Dutchess County Public Transit system operates numerous bus routes throughout Poughkeepsie. Depending on the specific route, bus stops would likely be within comfortable walking distance of Raymond Avenue, connecting the store to different neighborhoods. Furthermore, Poughkeepsie has a Metro-North train station, providing direct service to and from New York City (Grand Central Terminal). While not directly adjacent, this makes Zimmer Brothers Jewelers a reachable destination for clients from further afield who are seeking their specific expertise, particularly for custom work and repairs.
Based on customer feedback and the typical offerings of a full-service jewelry store, Zimmer Brothers Jewelers provides a range of services, with a strong emphasis on personalized craftsmanship:
The features and highlights of Zimmer Brothers Jewelers are best understood through the experiences of their customers:
Information regarding specific widespread promotions or special offers at Zimmer Brothers Jewelers is not explicitly detailed in the provided data. However, based on the nature of their business and the customer reviews, their primary "promotions" come in the form of the consistent value and quality they deliver, particularly in their standout areas.
Their core "offers" include:
For any current information on specific offerings or to discuss potential discounts on their services, it is always recommended to contact Zimmer Brothers Jewelers directly.
For inquiries, to schedule a consultation for custom work, or to learn more about their repair services, here is the direct contact information for Zimmer Brothers Jewelers:
Address: 39 Raymond Ave, Poughkeepsie, NY 12603, USA
Phone: (845) 454-6360
Mobile Phone: +1 845-454-6360
These contact details provide direct lines to their team, allowing you to easily call ahead, discuss your needs, or schedule a visit.
Zimmer Brothers Jewelers is a highly suitable choice for locals in the New York region, particularly for those in Poughkeepsie and the surrounding Hudson Valley, especially when it comes to custom jewelry design and repair services. While a single review indicated potential issues with coin/bullion appraisal pricing, the overwhelmingly positive feedback for their core jewelry services highlights where their true strength lies. For New Yorkers seeking a local jeweler who can expertly resize a family heirloom, create a bespoke engagement ring from scratch, or undertake intricate repairs with "amazing work and turnaround time" at "very reasonable pricing," Zimmer Brothers Jewelers comes highly recommended.
Their commitment to personalized service, clear communication throughout the custom design process, and dedication to exceeding expectations make them a trusted partner for cherished pieces. The convenience of their Raymond Avenue location in Poughkeepsie further enhances their appeal for local residents. By choosing Zimmer Brothers Jewelers for your custom jewelry needs or repairs, you are not only ensuring high-quality craftsmanship but also supporting a local business that strives to bring your vision to life with care and professionalism.
39 Raymond Ave, Poughkeepsie, NY 12603, USA
Get directionsJust stopped by Zimmer Brothers Jewelry in Poughkeepsie, NY, and I was honestly baffled by the experience. I brought in a 1/10 oz Gold Eagle (MS-70) and a 1/4 oz Platinum Eagle (MS-70) for appraisal. The lady at the front was very kind and professional, but when she came back with the offer from the guy in the back—hidden away like some mystery appraiser—I couldn’t believe it. They offered $175 for the gold coin, which is low to begin with, and then a shocking $25 for the platinum coin. That’s just insane considering its actual melt value, let alone the grade. The front desk rep was sweet and understanding, but whoever appraised those coins clearly doesn’t know—or care—about real value.
Apr 05, 2025 · Salty FemalesAbsolutely loved my experience. Had to have a family heirloom ring of my fiance's resized to fit and we also wanted to swap out the gem - every step of the process Zimmer Brothers gave me updates and we met multiple times to make sure everything was exactly what I wanted. I had a vision and they exceeded my expectations! Pricing was very reasonable too for the amazing work and turnaround time. I'm so happy we decided to shop local for our jewelry repair and will definitely be going back for any future jewelry needs! Highly recommend to anyone looking for custom work.
Aug 24, 2023 · Amanda PanzerMy wife and I enjoyed the service here. They were very helpful in making me a new wedding band. Mary Ellen, especially, was a joy to work with. I recommend them fully.
Mar 10, 2025 · Chibuzo AchinivuMaryEllen was excellent. The piece I requested was perfect and ahead of schedule! I was able to surprise my wife for Christmas. I appreciate the kind attention I received, especially during the holidays. Thank you again to MaryEllen and the entire staff!
Jan 02, 2025 · Carlo DiminicoI have been going to Zimmer Brothers for a while now as my family has too. MaryEllen helped me replicate my grandfather’s ring as best as we could and kept me updated throughout the entire process when it was being designed. I would recommend anyone looking for jewelry to stop into Poughkeepsie or Rhinebeck!
Apr 20, 2024 · Vincent811 Main St, Arlington, NY 12603, USA
353 Hooker Ave, Poughkeepsie, NY 12603, USA
677 Dutchess Turnpike suite 201, Poughkeepsie, NY 12603, USA
330 Main St, Poughkeepsie, NY 12601, USA
2600 South Rd, Poughkeepsie, NY 12603, USA
2 Alfred Dr, Poughkeepsie, NY 12603, USA
2036 South Rd, Poughkeepsie, NY 12601, USA
88 New Paltz Rd, Highland, NY 12528, USA
790 South Rd PK-4, Poughkeepsie, NY 12601, USA
2001 South Rd D-101, Poughkeepsie, NY 12601, USA
2001 South Rd Suite C216, Poughkeepsie, NY 12601, USA
2001 South Rd C114, Poughkeepsie, NY 12601, USA