4.0

I have been coming to Pennyweights for jewelry for many years and I always have a great experience. The jewelry is amazing quality and lasts a long time. The employees are all very sweet and kind and are always happy to help customers. I always recommend Pennyweights to people if they are looking to purchase jewelry and are great gifts for loved ones.

Alexis Taylor
  • Overview
  • (203) 966-7739
  • www.pennyweights.com

Hours

Monday 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Tuesday 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Wednesday 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Thursday 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Friday 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Saturday 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Sunday 12:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Pennyweights Introduce

For residents across Connecticut, finding a trusted and reliable local jewelry store is a true gem in itself. In the charming town of New Canaan, Pennyweights has long been a beacon for those seeking beautiful, quality jewelry, coupled with an unparalleled shopping experience. This article delves into what makes Pennyweights a standout destination for local users, from its convenient location to its remarkable selection and the dedicated service that has garnered a loyal following for over two decades.

In the realm of jewelry, personal connection and trust are paramount. Pennyweights embodies these values, offering a welcoming atmosphere where customers feel not just valued, but truly special. Whether you're in search of the perfect gift for a loved one, a timeless piece to add to your own collection, or simply exploring the latest trends, understanding the essence of Pennyweights will illuminate why it continues to be a go-to choice for so many across Connecticut. Their commitment to offering stylish, affordable, and high-quality jewelry is a testament to their enduring appeal in the community.

Location and Accessibility

Pennyweights is ideally situated at 108 Elm St, New Canaan, CT 06840, USA. This prominent location places it directly in the heart of New Canaan’s bustling downtown, an area known for its vibrant local businesses, boutique shops, and a friendly community atmosphere. Elm Street itself is a central thoroughfare, making the store easily identifiable and accessible for both residents of New Canaan and those traveling from neighboring Connecticut towns.

The central positioning on Elm Street means that Pennyweights is convenient for visitors arriving by various means. For those driving, there are often parking options available nearby, allowing for a comfortable and stress-free visit. The pedestrian-friendly nature of New Canaan’s downtown also makes it easy for those walking or enjoying a stroll through the town to pop in and explore the offerings. Being part of such an active and appealing commercial district allows visitors to combine their jewelry shopping with other errands or leisure activities, making a trip to Pennyweights a pleasant and integrated part of their day.

Services Offered

While Pennyweights is primarily celebrated for its curated selection of jewelry, its commitment to customer satisfaction often extends to various services that enhance the overall experience and address common jewelry needs.

  • Expert Jewelry Sales and Consultation: The core service of Pennyweights involves assisting customers in selecting the perfect piece of jewelry. Their staff are known for their knowledge and helpfulness, guiding individuals through their extensive collection to find items that match their style, occasion, and budget.
  • Gift Selection and Wrapping: A significant highlight mentioned by customers is the ability to find "perfectly wrapped PW gifts." This indicates that Pennyweights not only helps in selecting the right jewelry but also provides professional and attractive gift wrapping services, making the gifting process seamless and special for customers.
  • Personalized Shopping Experience: While not explicitly a "service" in the traditional sense, the consistent feedback from customers points to a highly personalized and welcoming shopping experience. The staff, including Geoff and Kelly, are noted for going "out of their way to make each customer feel special," which is an invaluable aspect of their offering.
  • Affordable Quality Jewelry: Pennyweights specializes in providing "beautiful, quality jewelry that is affordable and stylish." This focus on delivering value without compromising on quality is a key offering, allowing a wider range of customers to access fine jewelry for various occasions.
  • Curated Collections: Though not a service, the ongoing effort to curate and maintain a diverse and appealing collection of jewelry ensures that customers always have fresh and exciting options to choose from, catering to different tastes and trends.

Features / Highlights

Pennyweights is distinguished by a multitude of features and highlights that contribute to its long-standing reputation and strong customer loyalty.

  • Exceptional Customer Service: This is arguably Pennyweights' most celebrated feature. Customers consistently praise the staff, including owners Geoff and Kelly, for being "welcoming and friendly to all" and for going "out of their way to make each customer feel special." This level of personal attention creates a truly memorable and positive shopping environment.
  • Amazing Quality and Durability: Customers repeatedly highlight the "amazing quality" of the jewelry, noting that it "lasts a long time." This commitment to durable and well-crafted pieces ensures that purchases from Pennyweights are investments that stand the test of time, both aesthetically and structurally.
  • Affordable and Stylish Selection: The store is lauded for offering jewelry that is not only "beautiful" but also "affordable and stylish." This balance makes high-quality, fashionable pieces accessible to a broader audience, ensuring that there's something for everyone, regardless of their budget.
  • Perfectly Wrapped Gifts: The attention to detail extends to their gift-wrapping, which is frequently mentioned as "perfectly wrapped." This adds significant value for those purchasing gifts, elevating the presentation and making the unboxing experience truly special for recipients.
  • Community Pillar and Longevity: Having been a "go-to jewelry store for the last 20+ years," Pennyweights has established itself as a solid and reputable retailer in New Canaan. This longevity speaks volumes about their consistent quality, reliability, and deep roots within the community.
  • Wide Range of Occasions: The versatility of their collection makes Pennyweights suitable for buying gifts for "friends, family, teachers, babysitters & colleagues," indicating a broad appeal for various gifting needs.

Promotions or Special Offers

While specific, current promotions are best confirmed by directly contacting Pennyweights, it's common for long-standing local businesses to offer various incentives throughout the year. These might include seasonal sales, holiday specials, or unique promotions around popular gifting occasions like Valentine's Day, Mother's Day, or graduation season. Given their reputation for excellent customer service and their focus on providing value, it is advisable for interested customers to reach out via phone or visit their store in New Canaan to inquire about any ongoing or upcoming special offers that could enhance their shopping experience. Staying connected with their local presence is the best way to discover any exciting opportunities to purchase their high-quality, affordable jewelry.

Contact Information

For those in Connecticut looking to experience the charm and quality of Pennyweights, here is their contact information:

Address: 108 Elm St, New Canaan, CT 06840, USA

Phone: (203) 966-7739

Mobile Phone: +1 203-966-7739

Conclusion: Why this place is suitable for locals

For residents across Connecticut, Pennyweights in New Canaan represents much more than just a jewelry store; it's a cherished local institution. Its suitability for locals stems from a powerful combination of factors that cater directly to the needs and preferences of community members. The most significant aspect is the consistently praised customer service, where Geoff, Kelly, and their staff go above and beyond to make every individual feel special and valued. This personalized approach fosters a sense of trust and community that is often missing in larger retail environments.

Furthermore, the commitment to providing "beautiful, quality jewelry that is affordable and stylish" ensures that Pennyweights serves a wide demographic. Locals can find exquisite pieces for special occasions, thoughtful gifts for any recipient, or simply treat themselves without breaking the bank. The emphasis on quality means that purchases from Pennyweights are not fleeting trends but lasting treasures, providing excellent value for money. The convenience of its Elm Street location in downtown New Canaan makes it easily accessible for a quick visit or a leisurely shopping experience, fitting seamlessly into the daily lives of residents.

The fact that customers are willing to drive "2.5 hours" just to shop at Pennyweights, even after moving away, speaks volumes about the unique and irreplaceable experience it offers. This level of loyalty is built on decades of reliable service, consistent quality, and a genuine connection with its clientele. For anyone in Connecticut seeking a jeweler who offers not just products, but a truly delightful and trustworthy experience, Pennyweights is undoubtedly a solid and reputable choice that truly understands and serves its local community.

Pennyweights Photos

Pennyweights 5
Pennyweights 5
Pennyweights 5
Pennyweights 5
Pennyweights 5
Pennyweights 5
Pennyweights 5
Pennyweights 5
Pennyweights 5
Pennyweights 5

Pennyweights Location

Pennyweights

108 Elm St, New Canaan, CT 06840, USA

Get directions

Reviews

I have been coming to Pennyweights for jewelry for many years and I always have a great experience. The jewelry is amazing quality and lasts a long time. The employees are all very sweet and kind and are always happy to help customers. I always recommend Pennyweights to people if they are looking to purchase jewelry and are great gifts for loved ones.

May 16, 2025 · Alexis Taylor

Pennyweights has been our go-to jewelry store for the last 20+ years. Geoff, Kelly and their staff are welcoming and friendly to all. They go out of their way to make each customer feel special. They carry beautiful, quality jewelry that is affordable and stylish. I have bought dozens and dozens of the perfectly wrapped PW gifts for friends, family, teachers, babysitters & colleagues. Everyone is my circle knows that when they get a Pennyweights box that something special is inside. New Canaan is lucky to have such a solid and reputable retailer. Having moved away years ago, I now drive 2.5 hours to shop Pennyweights and it’s always worth the trip!

May 15, 2025 · LORA C

Pennyweights is a gem!! The owners Kelly & Geoff and staff are the best!! They are incredibly welcoming to everyone who walks through the door. I always feel so special when I go whether I’m buying for myself or others. So many great pieces. Look forward to seeing you soon. 💕

May 22, 2025 · valbanesi

Pennyweights is my go-to for gift giving! They have the best selection of silver jewelry and more. Great customer service and beautiful gift wrapping keep me coming back when I can. When I can’t I have ordered online and was equally happy with the selection and service.

May 15, 2025 · Kristi Bates

I love visiting Pennyweights when I am on the east coast for their unique selection of silver jewelry. When I can’t make it into the shop, I visit their website or reach out to owners Kelly and Geoff who are so kind and generous, and always up on the latest trends and have a beautiful eye for unique designs and suggestions! One of my favorite shops ever!! 💙

May 15, 2025 · Jennifer Battista

Jewelry Store Near Me

Brad & Vandy Reh Fine Jewelry

Brad & Vandy Reh Fine Jewelry

125 Elm St, New Canaan, CT 06840, USA

Stoneburst Creations

Stoneburst Creations

56 Haviland Rd, Stamford, CT 06903, USA

Peter Suchy Jewelers

Peter Suchy Jewelers

1137 High Ridge Rd, Stamford, CT 06905, USA

CT Gold & Silver

CT Gold & Silver

15 Danbury Rd, Wilton, CT 06897, USA

Heart of Gold Fine Jewelry, LLC

Heart of Gold Fine Jewelry, LLC

930 Hope St, Stamford, CT 06907, USA

Wilton Jewelers

Wilton Jewelers

27 Danbury Rd, Wilton, CT 06897, USA

NP Jewelers

NP Jewelers

934 High Ridge Rd, Stamford, CT 06905, USA

Puzzle Rings Creations LLC

Puzzle Rings Creations LLC

934 High Ridge Rd #2, Stamford, CT 06905, USA

Picali Jewelry & Boutique

Picali Jewelry & Boutique

72 Westchester Ave, Pound Ridge, NY 10576, USA

NAGI Jewelers

NAGI Jewelers

828 High Ridge Rd, Stamford, CT 06905, USA

Aretes y Más

Aretes y Más

48 Clinton Ave apt 1, Norwalk, CT 06854, USA