Paolo Costagli New York

I had the most amazing shopping experience at the Paolo Costagli Atelier working with Erika to find my Mother and Sister the perfect Christmas gifts. Erika was patient and accommodating of my picky nature. The gifts were loved by my family and we will continue to build on our collection of Paolo Costagli jewelry.

The first time I tried on a pair of Paolo Costagli's earrings I fell in love instantly. I now have a pair of his signature earrings and I can't stop wearing them! The workmanship is unparalleled and when I wear them I feel fabulous. Erika was an absolute pleasure to be served by. Her professionalism and customer service was excellent. Thank you for my beautiful earrings. I feel privileged to wear such art! X

We first learned of Paolo Costagli several years ago, when my wife was reading a travel magazine and spied a unique and very attractive ring that struck her. When she received that very ring as a gift a few months later, her response was what you would imagine. Several years and several additional beautiful pieces later, Paolo Costagli continues to be the most wonderful source for beautiful and unique pieces, and impeccable customer service. We cannot say enough about our experience. Whether in person at their NYC location or via email, it has been a joy to collaborate with them. Special shout out to Erika Watkins, Vice President of Sales and Marketing, who has on more than one occasion guided the shopping experience to ensure the right piece. On this last purchase, a secret valentine's gift for my wife, Erika and I coordinated via email on everything from potential piece images, sizing instructions, payment, and delivery instructions. If you or someone you know would welcome truly unique and beautiful jewelry, coupled with a wonderful experience, definitely explore Paolo Costagli.

I just love the jewelry made by Paolo. They have custom made 2 rings for me when I requested specific stones or rose gold in place of yellow gold. No extra charge just wonderful personalized service by Erika the company VP. They truly want you to love your purchases. Mine are exquisite!! Can't wait to buy more.

My wife has mentioned this brand to me for years, but I was unsure what item she would like best. I sent a message through the website contact from and was instantly contacted by Erika, the VP of Sales. Erika provided me an exceptional level of customer service. She worked directly with me to help find the right ring for my wife and even provided me with exactly what to say when I presented the gift to her. My wife loved the ring Erika helped me pick it out. She was shocked when she saw the gift wrapped Paolo Costagli box under the tree Christmas morning, but was completely speechless once she saw what was inside. I will definitely be coming to Erika for my wife's next gift.